Six Out, One Doubtful, and Two Questionable

tend to get injured more often, as coaches can't rotate the good players as much because they don't have depth.

Schoen needed to build adequate depth, but after four years the backups are worst than when he took over. Hence, more losing. Of course, the Giants FO will accuse Daboll and staff of not developing players (which is true to a point), while deflecting on Schoen not doing his job.

wonder if Collins and Gano will be put on IR. Somebody in another thread cited a comment by Daboll stating that roster moves beyond standard PS elevations could happen tomorrow. I think a columnist noted it as well.

with Holland missing time as well.

Daboll should be brought back!





/s

In comment 17002191 Anakim said:

Quote:

Daboll should be brought back! /s

I truly hope that is sarcasm

What a year for Adebo. Ooof.

No availability

In comment 17002178 JohnF said:

Quote:

tend to get injured more often, as coaches can't rotate the good players as much because they don't have depth. Schoen needed to build adequate depth, but after four years the backups are worst than when he took over. Hence, more losing. Of course, the Giants FO will accuse Daboll and staff of not developing players (which is true to a point), while deflecting on Schoen not doing his job.

I don't buy that. You can't have depth in the secondary to replace two safeties and 2 CB's at the same effing time. Come on. The Oline has had injuries and has been more than fine.

People see what they want to see.

Is depth the reason we lost to the Broncos?

Is depth the reason we lost to Dallas?

Is depth the reason we lost to the Chiefs?

Again, 2-7 sucks but if this team had won the Cowboys and Broncos games as they SHOULD have and were in position to, we are talking 4-5 and within range of a number of teams in the NFC and in second place in our own division, having split games with the first place team.

That is COACHING not the GM! You can blame Schoen for a ton of stuff but the Giants depth and talent at a number of positions is better than it has been in a long time.

I hate late season byes. This team desperately needs a rest period to get back healthy and the NFL gives them a buy when 75% of the season is done. Not to mention the gauntlet schedule.

dont see a difference between JMS and Schlottman

hurt his neck?

In comment 17002219 Jim in Forest Hills said:

Quote:

dont see a difference between JMS and Schlottman

That's true. Schlottman is pretty good depth. I'm glad we're getting Holland and Flott back.

In comment 17002183 Chris684 said:

Quote:

with Holland missing time as well.

Schoen's FA signings have been horrible. Almost as bad as Gettleman.

In comment 17002196 Sec 103 said:

Quote:

In comment 17002191 Anakim said: Quote: Daboll should be brought back! /s I truly hope that is sarcasm

The back slash and the S in his post means sarcasm.

In comment 17002230 kdog77 said:

Quote:

hurt his neck?

Sleeping

In comment 17002178 JohnF said:

Quote:

tend to get injured more often, as coaches can't rotate the good players as much because they don't have depth. Schoen needed to build adequate depth, but after four years the backups are worst than when he took over. Hence, more losing. Of course, the Giants FO will accuse Daboll and staff of not developing players (which is true to a point), while deflecting on Schoen not doing his job.

Sorry, but you are just wrong. This is the best group of backups we have had in 10 years.

The idiocy of BBI continues. Nobody has or can afford starting level players as backups.

In fact, I am being nice.. your post is just stupid.

In comment 17002261 bradshaw44 said:

Quote:

In comment 17002230 kdog77 said: Quote: hurt his neck? Sleeping

Gano is like me. A few days ago I was laying on the couch watching TV and got like stomach cramps sitting awkwardly. It was actually kind of agonizing and debilitating as I really couldn't stretch it out lol

In comment 17002274 section125 said:

Quote:

In comment 17002178 JohnF said: Quote: tend to get injured more often, as coaches can't rotate the good players as much because they don't have depth. Schoen needed to build adequate depth, but after four years the backups are worst than when he took over. Hence, more losing. Of course, the Giants FO will accuse Daboll and staff of not developing players (which is true to a point), while deflecting on Schoen not doing his job. Sorry, but you are just wrong. This is the best group of backups we have had in 10 years. The idiocy of BBI continues. Nobody has or can afford starting level players as backups. In fact, I am being nice.. your post is just stupid.

Oh yeah, Banks the #1 backup in the NFL, right? I'm sure you have no problem with him. Same with Hyatt and Neal. Teams should have called Schoen non stop and offered #2 and #3 picks for these guys.

So I guess all the other NFL GM's are stupid.

And no, I'm not saying Schoen needed starting players as backups. That's not realistic. I'm saying that we shouldn't have guys out there that aren't even NFL third stringers. And right now, Banks, Hyatt and Neal are hot garbage.

Other teams get injuries. Sure, their backups aren't as good as the starters, but they at least compete. We have too many guys who can't...or won't compete.

So if you think that's acceptable, then losing like the team has been doing is fine with you. I have higher expectations for team building after 4 years. I guess that's stupid, I should accept losing like you do.

Out:
▪️CB Paulson Adebo (Knee) could really use him
▪️WR Beaux Collins (Neck) worthless
▪️K Graham Gano (Neck) so what else is new
▪️DL Chauncey Golston (Neck) wasted FA signing
▪️LB Darius Muasau (Ankle) Big deal
▪️C John Michael Schmitz (Shin) Schlottmann is just as good

to get injured this year because he doesn't do anything?

Has JMS gone through one season where he isn’t injured?

In comment 17002230 kdog77 said:

Quote:

hurt his neck?

Dodging questions during his post-game interview.

In comment 17002210 jvm52106 said:

Quote:

In comment 17002178 JohnF said: Quote: tend to get injured more often, as coaches can't rotate the good players as much because they don't have depth. Schoen needed to build adequate depth, but after four years the backups are worst than when he took over. Hence, more losing. Of course, the Giants FO will accuse Daboll and staff of not developing players (which is true to a point), while deflecting on Schoen not doing his job. I don't buy that. You can't have depth in the secondary to replace two safeties and 2 CB's at the same effing time. Come on. The Oline has had injuries and has been more than fine. People see what they want to see. Is depth the reason we lost to the Broncos? Is depth the reason we lost to Dallas? Is depth the reason we lost to the Chiefs? Again, 2-7 sucks but if this team had won the Cowboys and Broncos games as they SHOULD have and were in position to, we are talking 4-5 and within range of a number of teams in the NFC and in second place in our own division, having split games with the first place team. That is COACHING not the GM! You can blame Schoen for a ton of stuff but the Giants depth and talent at a number of positions is better than it has been in a long time.

Schoen sucks ass. Anyone who doesn’t see it is a moron. Hyatt and Robinson ate his and his alone. Who went into the season w the weakest WR crew in the NFL. Who decided to cost pay for Gano.


They had two NFL ILBs inthe whole Roster. DTs still suck. Alexander is like 26-27 and barely plays. Nubin is a busy whom they took to take over for McKinney.


Two things can be true. Daboll sucks. Yup. But so does Schoen. Keeping him would be like telling the Capt of the Titanic it wasn’t his fault