Looks like Roger Craig made the HOF.

A HOF with this guy but not Eli

Dr. D : 7:33 pm : link

is really a fu*cking joke.

Gun to head

SHO'NUFF : 7:34 pm : link

would Niners fans choose Craig or CMC?

HIGH KNEES...

Brown_Hornet : 7:38 pm : link

...!

He had a couple of outstanding seasons

Matt in SGS : 7:38 pm : link

he was the first guy to get 1000 yards rushing & receiving in the same season. He was solid to outstanding from 1984-1989. Fell off badly in 1990 and we all thank him for coughing up the ball when Erik Howard hit him in the 1990 NFC Championship Game. Kind of coasted the last few seasons and didn't produce much.

A Hall of Famer? Well, if he is, Tiki should be in.

He is not a HOF from my memory

George from PA : 7:50 pm : link

Eli is more worthy

Craig had a habit

section125 : 7:52 pm : link

of fumbling in big situations, IIRC. Good player. Not sure he is HoFer.

RE: He had a couple of outstanding seasons

BlackLight : 7:52 pm : link

In comment 17098218 Matt in SGS said:

Quote:

he was the first guy to get 1000 yards rushing & receiving in the same season. He was solid to outstanding from 1984-1989. Fell off badly in 1990 and we all thank him for coughing up the ball when Erik Howard hit him in the 1990 NFC Championship Game. Kind of coasted the last few seasons and didn't produce much.

A Hall of Famer? Well, if he is, Tiki should be in.

I wouldn't complain if Tiki made it, but Craig has three Super Bowl rings, more Pro Bowl invites, and won AP OPOY. And what has always worked against Tiki's case is that he retired and the Giants won a Super Bowl the following season.

No way, he should be in the Hall of Good

PatersonPlank : 7:53 pm : link

Lots of RBs were better

Craig In And Tiki Not

Trainmaster : 7:56 pm : link

Is a crime.

He was also

Bill in UT : 7:56 pm : link

a pretty good pitcher. Bo Jackson lite?

Guy was barely a top 10 player

bceagle05 : 8:00 pm : link

on his own damn team but Eli gets knocked for not being a top five QB in the league during his era. There will be no outrage on First Take or talk radio tomorrow though.

LONG overdue

blueblood : 8:10 pm : link

Craig should be the HOF..

Craig vs Tiki

AlbanyGmen : 8:20 pm : link

Tiki was better!

I mean if Craig makes it

terz22 : 8:23 pm : link

Shouldn't this open the door for tiki?

Craig…hit behind the line of scrimmage..

DC Gmen Fan : 8:34 pm : link

And the GIANTS had the ball!!!

What a joke

HomerJones45 : 8:53 pm : link

apparently, playing for the 80's era Niners is your ticket to the HOF. From that time period, Curt Warner, Riggs, George Rogers, Herschel Walker were all better runners.

Soft spot for the guy

bluepepper : 9:29 pm : link

thanks to his fumble but HOF? Not even that close to be honest. Had he played on any other team, nobody would be considering him. Good news for Tiki though, his comps look real nice.